Ford Foundation Faculty Fellowship for study of science as background to modern poetry 1954–1955.
University of Rochester Summer Faculty Fellowship for Creative Writing. 1954
University of Rochester Summer Faculty Fellowship for Creative Writing. 1958
Lillian Fairchild Award (Rochester) for Best Work of Imagination. 1959
“Horatio” selected as a finalist for the Pulitzer Prize 1961
The city of Rochester declares May 11, 2002, Hyam Plutzik Day in recognition of his contributions to the community. “Sprig of Lilac” is noted as the official poem of the Lilac Festival.