"Bonnie Annie" (Child 24, Roud 172) is a folk ballad recorded from the Scottish and English traditions. Scottish texts are often called Bonnie Annie or The Green Banks of Yarrow, English texts are most often called The Banks of Green Willow. Other titles include The Undutiful Daughter, The High Banks O Yarrow, The Watery Grave, Green Willow, There Was a Rich Merchant that Lived in Strathdinah and The Merchant's Daughter.
Contents
- Synopsis
- Motifs
- Broadsides and early printed versions
- Versions collected from traditional singers
- Field recordings
- Recordings by revival singers and groups
- Discussion
- References
The ballad has been collected from traditional singers in Britain, Ireland, and the USA.
Synopsis
A young woman, either a lord's or a merchant's daughter, in some versions called Annie but often nameless, is seduced by a man who is sometimes a sea captain or a squire, or his occupation isn't mentioned. She falls pregnant. He suggests she steals "some of your father's goodwill and some of your mother's money" In other versions she steals gold from her father. They go aboard a ship. On the voyage she needs "women's help", presumably to help deliver her child, but this is not available. In some variants the ship will not sail, and either the lot falls on Annie or she asks to be thrown overboard "both me and my baby", in others her lover volunteers to throw her and the baby overboard for no apparent reason. He watches her swim, in some versions until she reaches the banks of green willow. He orders her to be buried, either in a coffin made of gold, or in a coffin with golden nails.
"Oh make my love a coffin,
Of the gold that shines yellow,
And she shall be buried
By the banks of green willow."
Collected from Mrs Overd, Langport, Somerset by Cecil Sharp in 1904.
Motifs
The motif of the lots and throwing a person from the ship may be derived from the tale of Jonah. Another ballad featuring these motifs is "Brown Robyn's Confession", (Child 57, Roud 3882).
Broadsides and early printed versions
Child published two versions, both from Scottish sources. The song doesn't seem to have been printed by broadside publishers.
Versions collected from traditional singers
The "Banks of Green Willow" variant was popular with traditional singers across the south of England, where 33 versions were collected in the early twentieth century (14 in Somerset, 8 in Devon). One version was collected in Gloucestershire and another from the Shropshire singer Fred Jordan. 11 versions under various titles were collected in Scotland, one in Ireland and two in the USA, both in Maine. Cecil Sharp reported the song as "very generally sung throughout Somerset".
Field recordings
There are two wax cylinder recordings of the Hampshire singer David Clements in the British Library Sound Archive, one recorded by George Butterworth, the other by Ralph Vaughan Williams. Since one seems to pick up where the other leaves off it seems possibke that they were recorded on the same day in 1909. Peter Kennedy recorded Mrs. Maguire of Belfast singing "The Green Banks of Yarrow" variant.
Recordings by revival singers and groups
This song has frequently been recorded by folk singers including A.L. Lloyd, Ewan McColl and Peggy Seeger, Nic Jones, Martin Carthy, Tony Rose, Dick Gaughan, Alison McMorland and Peta Webb as "The Green Banks of Yarrow", Steve Turner as "Bonnie Annie", Patti Reid as "Bonnie Annie".
Discussion
George Ritchie Kinloch, Child's source for one of his versions, states in his notes to "Bonnie Annie" that
"There is a prevalent belief among sea-faring people, that, if a person who has committed any heinous crime be on ship-board, the vessel, as if conscious of its guilty burden, becomes unmanageable, and will not sail till the offender is removed: to discover whom, they usually resort to the trial of those on board, by casting lots; and the individual upon whom the lot falls is declared the criminal, it being believed that Divine Providence interposes in this manner to point out the guilty person."