When a Stranger Calls Back

Plot summary

Julia Jenz (Jill Schoelen) arrives at Dr. Schifrin's house for a routine baby-sitting gig. Soon after Dr. Schifrin and his wife leave, a mysterious man knocks on the door. The man tells Julia that his car is broken down and asks to come inside to use the phone. Julia refuses but agrees to call his auto club. The phone is dead. Afraid to divulge that the phone is dead, Julia lies and says that she called the auto club. The auto club never arrives, so the man returns continuously to ask for help. Hoping he goes away, Julia continues to lie, but the conversations become increasingly sinister. Meanwhile, around the house, Julia vaguely notices things turning up out of place. Soon, however, it becomes obvious that someone is moving in and out of the house, at which time Julia discovers the children have been abducted. The intruder eventually comes after her; she narrowly escapes. It is revealed that the children Julia babysat were never found or heard from again.

Five years later, Julia is an introverted college student, still traumatized by the incident. To make matters worse, strange things happen from time to time in her apartment, and Julia believes that the intruder is once again stalking her. Jill Johnson (Carol Kane), now a counselor at the college Julia attends, offers to help with the trauma of the experience in the past and the current events taking place. Jill contacts John Clifford (Charles Durning) to come to Julia's aid and help figure out who is stalking her. For protection Jill helps Julia purchase a gun and teaches her how to use it. Julia begins noticing the stalker is entering her apartment while she's sleeping and decides to stay with Jill till she feels safe to return to her own home. Having been through a similar situation years before, Jill and a reluctant John investigate the incident from Julia's past and come to the conclusion the stalker may be a ventriloquist throwing his voice to make it seem like he was outside when speaking to Julia. While investigating Jill and John receive news that Julia has shot herself in the head while at her apartment; Jill promises to find the stalker. John eventually tracks down the stalker at a club where he performs as a ventriloquist just like he hypothesised but the stalker is able to get away. John is able to track down the stalker's home and finds pictures of Julia in the hospital and Jill's apartment. Having returned to her apartment Jill notices a carton of juice sitting out with the faces of the missing children from the first movie on it. Frightened Jill arms herself and the stalker begins to taunt her; the stalker is seen in makeup that allows him to seemingly 'disappear' from sight against Jill's apartment walls, in a struggle Jill is shot and John shows up just in time to shoot and kill the stalker.

Some time later Jill is recuperating in the hospital where Julia is located and is wheeled in to Julia's hospital room to discover her out of her coma, having survived the head wound.

Home media

When a Stranger Calls Back was released on DVD by Good Times Video on May 15, 2001.