Samiksha Jaiswal (Editor)

Napoleonist Syndrome

Updated on
Edit
Like
Comment
Share on FacebookTweet on TwitterShare on LinkedInShare on Reddit

The Napoleonist Syndrome is a psychological complex, or character disorder, underlying the attachment shown by members of a combatant country to the enemy leader, Napoleon.

Contents

It may be extended to cover parallel switches of allegiance in more modern times.

Nineteenth-century examples

During the 1790s, there was considerable sympathy outside France with the ideals of the French Revolution; but a decade later, after Napoleon had come to sole power, active sympathisers were much reduced in numbers: the collapse of Beethoven's Napoleonist Family romance, on hearing of Bonaparte's coronation as emperor, is a prime example of the change. Those Napoleonists that remained, however, came from all sides of the political spectrum - ranging from Queen Caroline to Radicals like William Hazlitt - something that has prompted a psychological explanation of their underlying motivation.

The common factor in that syndrome is taken to be an ambivalent relationship to the parent or parent of origins, leading to a rejection of national authority, and its projection abroad. The argument is particularly convincing in the case of a group of Radicals including Leigh Hunt and William Godwin, as well as Hazlitt - all the sons of dissenting ministers, whose religious beliefs they had rejected but whose influence on them remained substantial nevertheless. Their common revolt against their fathers led to a counter-identification with the heroic figure presented by Napoleon - his Promethean challenge to the existing order seeming to offer a stark contrast to the narrow authoritarianism represented both by their own fathers, and by the British Royal family.

Neo-Napoleonists

A similar syndrome may underlie later figures who projected their ideals on a distant, but larger than life tyrant, as in the case of Stalin and such double-agents as Guy Burgess and Kim Philby.

Literary analogues

  • Russian literature was pervaded by Napoleonism, from Pushkin to Raskolnikov.
  • Doris Lessing in The Golden Notebook parodied the Western Communist idealisation (paternalisation) of Stalin: "...working for us! For the world!...in custody of the destinies of us all....with a fatherly twinkle in his eyes".
  • References

    Napoleonist Syndrome Wikipedia