Carla Hughes

Early life and education

Carla Hughes was born on June 12, 1981, and was adopted by her uncle Carl and aunt Lynda Hughes when she was six weeks old. She was raised in Greenville, Mississippi. As a child, she excelled in horseback riding, beauty pageants and was an honors student.

Hughes earned a master's degree in education from Belhaven College and did graduate coursework in education at Delta State University. At the time of her arrest, she was pursuing a doctorate. She is also a member of Alpha Kappa Alpha sorority.

In 2004, she gave birth to a son.

Hughes started out her teaching career at an elementary school but then took a job as a 7th grade language arts teacher at a Jackson, Mississippi middle school. It was there where she met fellow teacher Keyon Pittman also a graduate of Alcorn State University located in Lorman, MS. The two began having an intimate relationship. At the same time, Pittman had a live-in fiancee, Avis Banks, who was pregnant.

Murder and Investigation

On the night of November 29, 2006, Avis Banks, a daycare worker, was found shot and stabbed to death in the garage of her Ridgeland, Mississippi home. Her body was discovered by her fiance Keyon Pittman, and it appeared as if the perpetrator had kicked in their back door. After discovering the body, Pittman called his co-worker Carla Hughes.

Hughes was later interrogated by police, where she initially denied her sexual relationship with Pittman and later denied having access to a gun. However, Hughes's cousin indicated to police, via an attorney, that he had loaned a loaded .38 caliber 5-shot revolver to Hughes shortly before the murder, and that she had returned the gun empty. Hughes was originally charged with accessory to murder after the fact, but on December 8, 2006, the charges were upgraded to two counts of capital murder.

Trial

Carla Hughes' trial began in October 2009. Prosecutors believed that Hughes killed Avis Banks so she could be with Pittman. Pittman testified for the prosecution on October 6, 2009, stating to jurors how he found Avis Banks' body in their garage and talked about his relationship with Hughes. In addition to Pittman's testimony, prosecutors were able to prove that Hughes' cousin's gun was the murder weapon and that Hughes shoes were used to kick in the door. Cell phone records also showed that Hughes was near Banks and Pittman's home at the time of the murder.

Hughes' attorneys Brandon Dorsey and Johnnie Walls continued to deny everything. They called Pittman a "bona fide womanizer" who did not want to be married with a child. They claimed that he had worn Hughes' shoes during the murder, and he discounted testimony about how Hughes' cellphone records placed her at the crime scene, claiming that she had a friend in the area. However, prosecutors continually stated that Pittman had an alibi at the time of the murder: that he was coaching basketball practice and texting another woman.

On October 12, 2009, Hughes pled the fifth, deciding not to testify in her own defense. The case was then handed over to the jury.

Verdict

After eight hours of deliberation, Hughes's jury announced they had reached a verdict on October 13, 2009. Hughes was found guilty on both counts of capital murder. Although Hughes could have faced the death penalty, she was instead sentenced to serve two consecutive life sentences without parole.

Aftermath

On August 30, 2010, a Madison County judge denied Carla Hughes' request for a new trial.

On June 21, 2012, the Mississippi Supreme Court affirmed the judgment of the Madison County Ciruit Court. Six issues were raised on appeal, all of which were found to be without error.

This case has been explored on episodes of true crime shows, Criminals at Work, Dateline NBC, Snapped, Forensic Files, Stolen Voices, Buried Secrets, Scorned: Love Kills, and Fatal Attraction.