"A Perfect Day" was phenomenally successful when first published in 1910. Eight million copies of the sheet music and five million recordings sold within a year; 25 million copies of the sheet music sold during Jacobs-Bond's lifetime, and many millions of recordings circulated as various artists performed the song on the fast-growing means of audio duplication. It was her most-requested number when Jacobs-Bond entertained the soldiers at U.S. Army camps in Europe during World War I. The popularity of "A Perfect Day" became so rampant that even Jacobs-Bond indicated in her autobiography that she had "tired" of hearing it. Along with "Just Awearyin' for You" and "I Love You Truly"—both published in 1901 as part of the collection Seven Songs as Unpretentious as the Wild Rose—"A Perfect Day" augmented Jacobs-Bond's career as the first woman who made a living from composing.
According to "Backstairs At the White House" by former White House seamstress Lillian Rogers Parks, "A Perfect Day" was the favorite song of First Lady Florence Harding. She often had it played at White House concerts.
"A Perfect Day" was in the ship's songbook when RMS Titanic made its fatal maiden voyage in 1912.
"A Perfect Day" has been frequently recorded in English. Otto Leisner's Norwegian translation was popularized by Sissel Kyrkjebø.
Besides the plaintive 1915 McKee Trio instrumental rendition linked in this article, "A Perfect Day" has been recorded by numerous artists from various backgrounds, including David Bispham, Bing Crosby (recorded December 13, 1950), Evan Williams, Clara Butt, Norwegian–American Eleanor Olson, Nelson Eddy, Jeanette MacDonald, Italian-American Rosa Ponselle, Blue Mountains Trio, Virgil Fox (organ only), Peggy Balensuela (singer) and William Hughes (piano), African Americans Mahalia Jackson and Paul Robeson, Swedish American Alan Lindquest, Englishmen John McHugh and Webster Booth, Austria's Richard Tauber, Australia's Judith Durham, The Fureys (Ireland), Germany's Annah Graefe, Scotland's Moira Anderson and English baritone Sir Thomas Allen accompanied by Scottish Malcolm Martineau as well as Scotsman Sydney MacEwan. Jo Stafford and Gordon MacRae recorded the song as a duet. On the screen accompanied by Barbara Stanwyck at the piano, Sterling Holloway sang "A Perfect Day" in the 1940 feature film Remember the Night. In 1945 German-American opera soprano Helen Traubel recorded an andante interpretation. In 1962 Norma Zimmer sang "A Perfect Day" in response to thousands of requests on the Lawrence Welk Show. In "MARCEL THE SHELL WITH SHOES ON, THREE," an October 2014 video by Dean Fleischer-Camp and Jenny Slate, Marcel sings this song at the conclusion of the video, claiming to have learned it at camp.
Danish journalist Otto Leisner (1917–2008) translated "A Perfect Day" into Norwegian as "En deilig dag"; this translation has been recorded by, among others, Sissel Kyrkjebø.
"A Perfect Day" exemplifies the sentimentality popular in the late Victorian and post-Victorian era but has risen above such a sequestered view by nuances of studied reflection which, combined with the chord progressions of Jacobs-Bond's tune, have borne its appeal across time and cultural boundaries. "A Perfect Day" persists as an elegy using the analogy of the end of day as the end of life.
In 1929, at Lake Arrowhead, California, with "A Perfect Day" playing on a phonograph, Jacobs-Bond's only child, Frederick Jacobs Smith, committed suicide.