The 1923 All-Big Ten Conference football team consists of American football players selected to the All-Big Ten Conference teams chosen by various selectors for the 1923 Big Ten Conference football season.
Ray Eklund, Minnesota (BE; NB-1; WE-1)
Elmer A. Lampe, Chicago (NB-1; WE-2)
John W. Hancock, Iowa (BE; WE-3)
Lowell Otte, Iowa (WE-1)
Russell Irish, Wisconsin (NB-2; WE-3)
Frank Rokusek, Illinois (NB-2; WE-2)
Marty Below, Wisconsin (BE; NB-1; WE-1)
Stanley Muirhead, Michigan (BE; NB-1; WE-1)
Leo Kriz, Iowa (NB-2; WE-2)
Gowdy, Chicago (NB-2; WE-3)
Boni Petcoff, Ohio State (WE-2)
Louis Gross, Minnesota (WE-3)
Jim McMillen, Illinois (BE; NB-1; WE-1)
Adolph Bieberstein, Wisconsin (BE; WE-2)
George Abramson, Minnesota (NB-1)
Lloyd Rohrke, Chicago (WE-1)
Joe Pondelik, Chicago (NB-2)
Thomas Butler, Indiana (NB-2; WE-3)
Gay, Minnesota (WE-2)
Bill Fleckenstein, Iowa (WE-3)
Jack Blott, Michigan (BE; NB-1; WE-1)
Billy Young, Ohio State (NB-2)
Ralph Claypool, Purdue (WE-2)
King, Chicago (WE-3)
Hoge Workman, Ohio State (NB-1; WE-1)
Irwin Uteritz, Michigan (NB-2)
Harry A. Hall, Illinois (WE-2)
Malcolm Graham, Minnesota (WE-3)
Red Grange, Illinois (BE; NB-1; WE-1)
Earl Martineau, Minnesota (BE; NB-1; WE-2)
Harry Kipke, Michigan (BE [qb]; NB-2; WE-1)
Bill McElwain, Northwestern (NB-2; WE-3)
Jack Harris, Wisconsin (WE-2)
Cully Lidberg, Minnesota (WE-3)
Merrill Taft, Wisconsin (BE; NB-1; WE-1)
Earl Britton, Illinois (NB-2; WE-3)
J. Thomas, Chicago (WE-2)
BE = Billy Evans released an all-conference team based on his polling of the conference's head coaches, with eight of ten providing their votes
NB = Norman E. Brown
WE = Walter Eckersall
Bold = first-team selection by a majority of the selectors listed above
