The 1916 All-Western college football team consists of American football players selected to the All-Western teams chosen by various selectors for the 1916 college football season.
Bert Baston, Minnesota (ECP-1) (CFHOF)
Chic Harley, Ohio State (ECP-1) (CFHOF)
Frederick I. Norman, Northwestern (ECP-2)
Charles Bolen, Ohio State (ECP-2)
George Hauser, Minnesota (ECP-1)
Fred Becker, Iowa (ECP-1)
Manley R. Petty, Illinois (ECP-2)
Frank A. R. Mayer, Minnesota (ECP-2)
Charles Higgins, Chicago (ECP-1)
Gilbert S. Sinclair, Minnesota (ECP-1)
C. L. Eklund, Minnesota (ECP-2)
Charlie Bachman, Notre Dame (ECP-2) (CFHOF)
John L. Townley, Jr., Minnesota (ECP-1)
Walter Niemann, Michigan (ECP-2)
Bart Macomber, Illinois (ECP-1) (CFHOF)
Claire Long, Minnesota (ECP-2)
Paddy Driscoll, Northwestern (ECP-1) (CFHOF/PFHOF)
John Maulbetsch, Michigan (ECP-1) (CFHOF)
Hal Hansen, Minnesota (ECP-2)
Stan Cofall, Notre Dame (ECP-2)
Pudge Wyman, Minnesota (ECP-1)
Bob Koehler, Northwestern (ECP-2)
Bold = consensus choice by a majority of the selectors
ECP = E. C. Patterson in Collier's Weekly
CFHOF = College Football Hall of Fame
