The 1909 All-Western college football team consists of American football players selected to the All-Western teams chosen by various selectors for the 1909 college football season.
Harlan Page, Chicago (ECP-1, WE)
James Dean, Wisconsin (ECP-2, WE)
Walter Henry Rademacher, Minnesota (ECP-1)
Frederick L. Conklin, Michigan (ECP-2)
James Walker, Minnesota (ECP-1, WE)
George Philbrook, Notre Dame (ECP-1)
Ralph Dimmick, Notre Dame (WE)
F. E. Boyle, Wisconsin (ECP-2)
Homer W. Dutter, Indiana (ECP-2)
Albert Benbrook, Michigan (ECP-1, WE) (CFHOF)
Sam Dolan, Notre Dame (ECP-1, WE)
Glenn D. Butzer, Illinois (ECP-2)
Harry W. Powers, Minnesota (ECP-2)
Andrew W. Smith, Michigan (ECP-2, WE)
Henry E. Farnum, Minnesota (ECP-1)
John McGovern, Minnesota (ECP-1, WE) (CFHOF)
Otto E. Seiler, Illinois (ECP-2)
Dave Allerdice, Michigan (ECP-1, WE)
Joe Magidsohn, Michigan (ECP-1, WE)
Crawley, Chicago (ECP-2)
Harry "Red" Miller, Notre Dame (ECP-2)
E. T. Pickering, Minnesota (ECP-1)
Robert E. Vaughan, Notre Dame (WE)
John Wilce, Wisconsin (ECP-2) (CFHOF)
Bold = consensus choice by a majority of the selectors
ECP = E. C. Patterson for Collier's Weekly
WE = Walter Eckersall in the Chicago Tribune
CFHOF = College Football Hall of Fame
