William Keogh

Background

He was born in Galway, son of William Keogh, clerk of the Crown for Kilkenny, and his wife Mary ffrench. He went to Dr Huddard's school in Dublin, and graduated from the University of Dublin: he was called to the Bar in 1840, and became in Queen's Counsel 1849. No-one has ever questioned his intellectual abilities. He was a superb speaker both in public and private, he founded a well-known debating society, the Tail-end Club, and published several books on law, politics and literature. Despite his later reputation for eccentricity and bad temper, as a young man he was considered to be the best of company, being genial, good humoured and a superb conversationalist. He joined the Connaught circuit where he rapidly acquired a large practice, due it was said to his eloquence and impressive presence; these gifts soon turned him towards politics.

He married Kate Rooney in 1841; they had one son, and a daughter Mary, who married James Murphy, judge of the High Court.

Political career

In 1847 Keogh was elected MP for Athlone. In 1851 he was one of the founders of the Catholic Defence Association; he was re-elected for Athlone in 1852. In the latter year he helped found the Independent Irish Party, which was popularly known as "the Pope's Brass Band". The new party was pledged to repeal the Ecclesiastical Titles Act and to further the cause of tenant reform, and most crucially its members gave an explicit promise not to take office but instead to hold the balance of power at Westminster. In this they were at first successful, helping to vote out the administration of Lord Derby, who was replaced by Lord Aberdeen.

Within months of promising not to take office, Keogh (together with his friend John Sadleir) made the decision which destroyed his reputation in his own lifetime and far beyond his death: he accepted office in the Aberdeen Government, becoming first Solicitor-General for Ireland, and then Attorney-General for Ireland in 1855. His decision was seen by the Irish electorate as an unforgivable betrayal of a solemn pledge and his name, along with Sadleir's, entered the Irish political vocabulary. Even a century later, John A. Costello turned down the offer by Éamon de Valera to make him a Supreme Court judge on the ground that he "did not wish face charges of being another Sadleir or Keogh".

Judicial career

In 1856 Keogh was appointed a judge of the Irish Court of Common Pleas. On the grounds of legal ability no one could dispute that he was highly qualified for judicial office, but unfortunately his conduct as a judge did nothing to restore the damage to his reputation. He was a man of strong opinions, which were always expressed forcefully, and his hot temper led to frequent quarrels with counsel. On one occasion Peter O'Brien, the future Lord Chief Justice of Ireland, was threatened with removal from Court. It must be said in Keogh's defence that, having recovered his temper, he apologised to O'Brien in open Court and in the presence of the assembled Bar. This suggests that Keogh, who as a young man had been famed for geniality and good humour, was not acting out of malice, but rather suffering from stress and ill-health.

Keogh's conduct of the "Fenian Trials" of 1865–6 and the savage sentences which were handed down there were much criticised, although his defenders said that Charles Kickham at least had been treated as leniently as the case allowed. In non-political cases he had a good reputation: if not a profound lawyer, he had the ability to quickly see the essential point of a case.

Further damage was done to his reputation by his decision on the Galway election petition case of 1872, where William Le Poer Trench, the unsuccessful candidate, petitioned to unseat the winner, John Philip Nolan, on the grounds of intimidation and undue pressure from the Catholic clergy. According to Delaney, Keogh's judgment took nine hours to read and "was delivered in an extremely biased manner and did nothing to enhance the reputation of the judiciary". Much of it seems to have been a diatribe against the Catholic hierarchy, which struck the audience as coming very strangely from a former member of the "Pope's Brass Band". There was a public uproar, and the Government had to move to defeat a motion in the House of Commons calling for Keogh's removal from the bench. On foot of the judgment the Government's Law officers, much to their own embarrassment, felt obliged to prosecute Patrick Duggan, Bishop of Clonfert and they were visibly relieved when he was acquitted.

Last years and death

In his last years, Keogh showed increasing signs of eccentricity, in the face of unrelenting public hostility from much of the Catholic population. His public clash with Peter O'Brien, which probably occurred in 1877, suggests that his bad temper was the result of stress rather than ill nature, and the reminisces of Oliver Burke demonstrate that he could still show considerable charm and good humour on occasion. In 1878 he travelled abroad to Belgium and Germany in an effort to regain his health, but on 19 August 1878 he attacked his valet with a straight razor in a fit of delirium, and was confined to a hospital. While he may have recovered his sanity, he continued to decline physically and died in Bingen am Rhein 30 September 1878. He was buried in Bonn.

Reputation

Keogh's death did nothing to lessen the hostility to him at home; the Irish newspapers heaped abuse on him, causing The Times of London to protest that in any country but Ireland his talents would have won him popularity and respect. There is no doubt of his intellectual gifts, and his friends recalled the charm and good humour he had shown in his earlier years. The picture of him in Burke's Anecdotes of the Connaught Circuit, published a few years after Keogh's death, is largely favourable. However, as McCullagh points out, not many politicians so damage their reputations that they are still spoken of with contempt a century later; and despite Keogh's gifts, one must conclude that much of the damage to his reputation was self-inflicted.

The inscription on the Cormack brothers memorial at Loughmore – placed there 32 years after Keogh's death – was typical of the continuing hostility to him.