Wide Eyed and Mystified

Critical reception

Allmusic's Jared Johnson said that the album title "is a line in the infectious track "The More," referring to the awe with which we look at God." Johnson called the album a "masterly crafted melodic rock." Johnson evoked that "the theme is uplifting, but you never feel like the guys are talking down to you."

CCM Magazine's Andrea Bailey noted how the lyrics on this album "indicate a deep, seasoned relationship with the Lord, subtly interweaving paraphrased scripture with themes of love and surrender". Bailey proclaimed this album to be a "drive-with-the-windowsdown fare that rocks more smartly and cleanly than ever."

Christianity Today's Russ Breimeier alluded to how the album as "successfully captures both styles. Combining a pounding piano with thick guitars".

Cross Rhythms's Mike Rimmer praised this as being "their absolute best and this is my first candidate for album of the year 2006."

Jesus Freak Hideout's Matt Johnson acclaimed "If you pass on this one, you're making a big mistake. Not only is this the best yet from downhere, but it's also one of the best records of the year to this point! Downhere fans will be eating this up. Pop-rock fans will be hard pressed to find anything better for their money, and people just looking for a more 'artsy' approach at popular Christian music would do well by themselves to not let this one slip through the cracks. This could be the sleeper hit of the year!"

New Release Tuesday's Kevin Davis also praised this as being "literally Unbelievable in its greatness."

Track listing

All tracks written by Jason Germain, Marc Martel.

Singles

Accolades

This album won a 2007 Juno Award for Contemporary Christian/Gospel Album of the Year.