Viewing Party

Plot

Michael Scott (Steve Carell) becomes frustrated when Kevin Malone (Brian Baumgartner) refers to Gabe Lewis (Zach Woods) as his boss. Erin Hannon (Ellie Kemper) and Gabe invite the office over to Gabe's house for a Glee viewing party. When the show starts, Michael and Gabe get into an argument over how high the volume should be. After taking turns raising and lowering the volume, Michael retreats to Gabe's bedroom, hoping that his employees will follow him there. Meanwhile, Pam Halpert (Jenna Fischer) has been having a hard time with getting her daughter CeCe to go to sleep at night, so Dwight Schrute (Rainn Wilson) picks her up to try to calm her down. Pam is stunned that CeCe becomes completely quiet in Dwight's hands.

Jim Halpert (John Krasinski) changes the channel from the Glee episode so he can check sports scores. Oscar Martinez (Oscar Nunez) asks Jim to change the channel back to Glee, but discovers that Erin had neglected to record the episode. To avoid his co-workers' anger, Jim goes into the bedroom to see Dwight holding a sleeping CeCe. Angela Martin (Angela Kinsey) comes in and demands that Dwight meet her outside for fulfillment of their sex contract. Determined to put an end to CeCe's "reverse cycling", Pam persuades Dwight to stay with the baby under the condition that Jim feeds Dwight pizza and beer while Pam goes outside to tell Angela that Dwight cannot see her.

Andy Bernard (Ed Helms) is growing increasingly jealous of Gabe's relationship with Erin. While observing Gabe's room, Ryan Howard (B. J. Novak) tells him that a Chinese virility supplement that Gabe keeps in his room is incredibly potent. Once alone Andy drinks the entire bottle of the supplement, which makes him intoxicated, prompting him to admit his jealousy to Phyllis Vance (Phyllis Smith). Phyllis volunteers to talk to Erin and find out if she is having sex with Gabe, but as Phyllis is fairly intoxicated herself, her inquiries segue into an explicit account of her sexual experiences with her husband Bob, which mortifies Erin. Andy's intoxication turns into sickness, and he ultimately retreats to Gabe's room and vomits on the bed.

Becoming irritated that no one joined in him in walking out on Gabe, Michael goes outside and pulls the cable connection, causing it to turn off. Hysteria erupts, and Michael becomes self-conscious over the commotion he has caused. He goes outside to fix the cable. There he is discovered by Erin, who throughout the evening has been trying to encourage Michael to bond with Gabe. Michael, still indignant over the idea that his office views Gabe as his boss, is initially irritated by her efforts, but eventually realizes that Erin views him as a father figure. He jokes around and tells her to go to her room, leading to a bonding moment between the two. As he leaves the party, Michael brings Gabe into the joke by threatening to kill him if he breaks Erin's heart.

Production

The episode was written by Jon Vitti, a long-time writer of The Simpsons. It was his first writing credit for The Office after joining the staff the show in the seventh season as a consulting producer. It was directed by Ken Whittingham, who has directed several episodes of The Office previously.

The Season Seven DVD contains a number of deleted scenes from this episode. Notable cut scenes include Gabe inviting Stanley to his party and Stanley's reaction, Michael making fun of Gabe and then noting in a talking head that he does not really know Gabe, Michael raiding Gabe's kitchen cabinet for additional items to add to his pizza, Michael comparing himself to Tom Hanks in the 1988 film Big and Gabe to Hanks in the 1993 film Philadelphia, Michael trying his pizza, only to spit it out, and Pam and Jim marveling at CeCe sleeping.

Reception

"Viewing Party" aired on NBC on November 11, 2010. In its original American broadcast, it was viewed by an estimated 7.15 million viewers and received a 3.6 rating/10 percent share among adults between the ages of 18 and 49. This means that 3.6 percent of all 18- to 49-year-old households watched the episode, and ten percent of that demographic had their televisions tuned to the channel at any point. The Baltimore NBC affiliate carried the Ravens/Falcons NFL game, so ratings for the regular Thursday NBC programming were lower than usual.

Myles McNutt of The A.V. Club awarded the episode a "B". He compared it to the earlier seventh season episode "Sex Ed", writing that both featured "a Michael story wherein a large collection of unfortunate behaviors is capped off with a moment of sincerity"; however, McNutt criticized this narrative structure, calling it "a bit cheap". Despite this, he felt that Dwight's subplot "was successful in that it strayed true to the office dynamic", and that the actual viewing of the Glee episode was a "highlight" because it showcased the characters "fall[ing] into some really fun (and familiar tropes." Bonnie Stiernberg of Paste magazine awarded the episode an 8.4 out of 10, and called it "a solid episode". She argued that "it left me wanting to tune in next week and see what’ll happen next", largely because of the "surprising" amount of character development.

Dan Forcella of TV Fanatic awarded the episode four out of five stars. He was complimentary towards the main plot, and he felt empathy towards Michael because he felt that "Gabe is the absolute worst". In addition, Forcella wrote that Pam and Jim's subplot "had its moments, as well", and called the scene featuring Jim feeding Dwight pizza "fantastic". Not all reviews were glowing, however. Alan Sepinwall gave the episode a critical review, calling it "dreadful". Although he said it was better than "Christening", he felt that "so, so much of the episode didn't work". Sepinwall felt that the major problem with the episode was that it was "lifeless" and "light on jokes", and only featured "Michael being petulant and crabby for a whole episode", rather than featuring him in a character study. He concluded that "Ellie Kemper and Steve Carell almost were able to save the episode in the closing moments with Erin's reaction to Michael declaring that he's not her father, [but] it came far too late in an episode that was more concerned with Andy vomit humor."