The Good Neighbor (film)

Plot

Ethan (Miller) and Sean (Gilchrist) are tech-savvy high-school teenagers who decide to prank their neighbor, Harold Grainey (Caan), by convincing him that his house is haunted. When Grainey leaves home one afternoon, the two set up equipment to simulate the haunting, as well as hidden cameras which will broadcast Grainey's reactions.

As the basis for a school project, Ethan requests Sean's assistance in setting up hidden cameras at Grainy's home so both can view a person's unfiltered reaction to being haunted by a poltergeist, despite Sean's initial reservations. The cameras are set up so that both can monitor Grainey's reactions for 6 weeks live from computers in Ethan's bedroom. Grainey has a reputation for being hostile, a recluse, and a "creepy old man" in the neighbourhood, which makes it easier for Ethan to justify choosing him as his subject.

Ethan starts to initiate activities aimed at unsettling Grainey, to make him believe the house is haunted, including making the kitchen door bang loudly in the middle of the night, disabling the heating system (which causes the bedroom window to shatter because of the freezing temperature), and activating the music player in the middle of the night.

But both Sean and Ethan are mystified by Grainey's ability to withstand all these strange occurrences. In one instance, they observe Grainey being disturbed by all the strange noises and then going down to the house's basement. The duo are not able to observe what he does, as they were not able to set up a camera there. Grainey goes down at about 11:30 p.m. and only emerges after 7:30 a.m. This leaves Ethan perplexed, and he vows to determine the reason.

Throughout the movie, we are shown flashbacks of Grainey and his wife. These flashbacks are all linked with the "paranormal" activities that the boys try to use to unsettle Grainey. For example, a flashback shows Grainey's wife dancing to music at 3am and crying and one of the activities the boys do is play the same music at a similar time. Another example is how Grainey's wife used to complain about the door not shutting correctly and banging. The first activity the boys did was slam the door continuously, leading to Grainey destroying it with an axe.

In the meantime, Ethan throws a Halloween party, and Sean and his new girlfriend decide to make out in a spare bedroom. His girlfriend notices a camera installed on top of the bed, which leaves Sean enraged. In an argument with Ethan, Sean discloses to Ethan that he knows the true reason why Ethan has targeted Grainey: Grainey was responsible for sending Ethan's father to jail many years ago. Ethan's father was an alcoholic who beat his wife regularly. During one such episode, Ethan's mother ran up to Grainey seeking his help. Grainey informed the police which led to Ethan's father being jailed and ultimately getting divorced from his wife. Ethan believes Grainey is responsible for destroying his family and making him lose his father.

Sean asks Ethan to return all his equipment, but Ethan refuses, threatening Sean with the fact that the equipment was purchased using his credit card and that it is covered in Sean's fingerprints. In the middle of their argument, they observe Grainey's cat toppling over one of the living room cameras. Ethan runs to his home to collect the camera, and in doing so finds the basement door unlocked. He goes down to find that Grainey has been hiding his deceased wife's used medical supplies all along as a way for him to remember her. It is then revealed in a series of flashbacks that Grainey loved his wife dearly, and he had set up a room where he could take care of her, including arranging a nurse. The viewer then realises that every activity performed by the boys related to Grainey's wife somehow and Grainey is convinced that he is being haunted by his wife. Earlier in the movie, a police officer goes to his house claiming someone made a complaint about a woman screaming from the basement, when in actuality it was Ethan and Sean. Ethan lifts a bell which Grainey gifted, causing the bell to make a sound which awakes Grainey. Fearing for his safety, Ethan hides in the living room, placing the bell on a table. Grainey sees the bell, and a flashback is shown when Grainey first gifts the bell saying that whenever she needed him, she only had to ring the bell. Grainey took the bell noise that awoke him and the fact that the bell was on the table led Grainey to believe it was as a sign that his wife wants him to be with her, and so he kills himself with his gun.

Ethan and Sean are arrested and sentenced to 2 years' probation and 500 hours community service. Leaving the courthouse, Ethan is surrounded by a slew of reporters and cameras. Having finally gained the attention he admitted to craving in an earlier scene, a slight smile appears on his face. Sean looks horrified as he realizes the ordeal may have sent his friend down a dark path.

Cast

Release

The Austin, Texas premiere, through the South by Southwest Film Festival, was well attended and featured appearances from the director, producers and stars.

On May 10, 2016, Variety announced that Vertical Entertainment had acquired North American theatrical distribution rights, with a release tentatively planned for fall of 2016. The film was scheduled to be released on September 16, 2016.

Reception

The South by Southwest premiere yielded mixed reactions. Dennis Harvey of Variety noted that, despite featuring few locations, the film "doesn’t suffer from staginess or claustrophobia", though he pined for "more insight into the protagonists’ family, friends and community."

Trace Thurman of Bloody Disgusting singled out James Caan, saying that he delivered "an understated performance with extremely minimal dialogue." Likewise, Michael Roffman of Consequence of Sound praised Caan's performance, but felt that it was lost in "erratic sequencing."