The Dismemberment Plan Is Terrified

Composition

Musically, the album can be described as a bridge between hardcore and noise rock. The track "That's When the Party Started" has a synthpop feel, while the fourth track on the album, "Academy Award", is featured as a remix by Cex on the band's final album A People's History of the Dismemberment Plan. It is the only song from The Dismemberment Plan Is Terrified to be remixed for it. "The Ice of Boston" was later released on an extended play of the same name, during their brief stint with Interscope Records. The song is spoken-word and contains references to songwriter Jonathan Richman and singer-songwriter Gladys Knight's song "Midnight Train to Georgia". Dismemberment Plan lead singer Travis Morrison described the album as "very confrontational", saying "it’s the least melodic record we have, it’s the most dedicated to hip-hop record we have".

Reception

The Dismemberment Plan Is Terrified received positive reviews from music critics. Brian Raftery of AllMusic commented that the album was not as good as The Dismemberment Plan's debut album, !, but nevertheless named "That's When the Party Started", "The Ice of Boston", and "Do the Standing Still" as standout tracks of the album. Metroactive praised the album for being "wonderfully varied", also saying "no two tracks sound alike". The review concluded with the reviewer calling the album "a mess that's hard to resist."

American music critic Robert Christgau called the album "surprisingly thoughtful for posthardcore. And from the way the guitars and such come crashing down to break up a good party and set off a better one." Joe Gardne of The A.V. Club published a positive review, saying "Odds are good that you'll find something you like right off the bat, and the rest will grow on you before you realize it." Tiny Mix Tapes wrote that with The Dismemberment Plan Is Terrified, the band "completely annihilates the term sophomore slump. Mr. Morisson's vocal styling on this album are at their most experimental and work very well over the rambunctious music." Despite The Dismemberment Plan Is Terrified not being "radio friendly", it led to major record label Interscope Records signing the band due to its strength.

Track listing

All music composed by The Dismemberment Plan.

Personnel

The following people were involved in the making of The Dismemberment Plan Is Terrified: