P.S. I Still Love You

Plot

After the fight that occurred at the Coveys' recital party, Lara Jean realizes that she has fallen for Peter. Hoping to reconcile, Lara Jean heads over to Peter's house with the love letter she hoped for him to read. After a brief talk, the two kiss and decide they want to be a real couple. At school, Lara Jean discovers that someone going by the name of Anonybitch has posted a video of Lara Jean and Peter making out in the hot tub on the day of the ski trip. A rumor goes around the school that the two were having sex. After seeing the video distributed around the school, one at a schooled assembly, Peter gets furious and goes on stage to warn Anonybitch to not mess with Lara Jean.

Before Margot leaves to go back to Scotland, she tells Lara Jean to get a job. Taking Margot's advice, Lara Jean volunteers to start a scrapbooking class at Belleview, where she meets Stormy, an elderly woman who has a feisty temper. Stormy gives Lara Jean relationship advice, all while being nosy about Lara Jean's relationship.

One day, Lara Jean receives a letter from the mail from John Ambrose McClaren, telling her that he received the love letter she wrote him. Lara Jean and John start to converse through letters to one another. They quickly become pen pals and when Lara Jean finds out that the neighborhood tree house she and her middle school friends used to hang out in and where they buried a time capsule In will soon be cut down, she decides to throw a going away reunion party and invites John. In the mean time, Lara Jean and Peter's relationship is a bit strained because Peter is spending a lot of time with his ex, Genevieve. At the treehouse party, Peter brings Genevieve while knowing Lara Jean purposefully didn't want her to come. Lara Jean also finds out that Peter and Gen were hanging out before the party, prompting her to become suspicious, and a little jealous, of Peter and Gen's 'relationship.' During the treehouse party, Lara Jean distracts herself from Peter by focusing on her childhood friend John Ambrose McClaren. They opened their greatest treasures in the time capsule that they buried from seventh grade. After emptying the time capsule, they decided to play a game called "Assasins" which they used to play before. As a prize, the winner gets a wish. Lara Jean was determined to win since she never got the chance to be a winner of the game. Lara Jean and Peter broke up as Lara Jean discovered that Peter knew that Genevieve took the video in the hot tub. Lara Jean ended up winning the game and wished for things to go back to the way they were between her and Peter.

Reception

This novel has reached number two on The New York Time's Best Seller List.