NL
Ralph Kiner, 7 (1946–1952)
Gavvy Cravath, 3 (1913–1915)
Chuck Klein, 3 (1931–1933)
Mel Ott, 3 (1936–1938)
Mike Schmidt, 3 (1974–1976)
AL
Babe Ruth, 6 (1926–1931)
Harry Davis, 4 (1904–1907)
Frank Baker, 4 (1911–1914)
Babe Ruth, 4 (1918–1921)
Harmon Killebrew, 3 (1962–1964)
Ken Griffey, Jr., 3 (1997–1999)
Alex Rodriguez, 3 (2001–2003)
MLB
Ralph Kiner, 6 (1947–1952)
Babe Ruth, 4 (1918–1921)
Babe Ruth, 4 (1926–1929)
Mark McGwire, 4 (1996–1999)
Gavvy Cravath, 3 (1913–1915)
Mike Schmidt, 3 (1974–1976)
Note that private researchers, such as baseball-reference.com, dispute Cobb's 1910 title.
NL
Rogers Hornsby, 6 (1920–1925)
Honus Wagner, 4 (1906–1909)
Tony Gwynn, 4 (1994–1997)
Stan Musial, 3 (1950–1952)
Tony Gwynn, 3 (1987–1989)
AL
Ty Cobb, 9 (1907–1915)
Nap Lajoie, 4 (1901–1904)
Rod Carew, 4 (1972–1975)
Wade Boggs, 4 (1985–1988)
Ty Cobb, 3 (1917–1919)
Miguel Cabrera, 3 (2011–2013)
MLB
Ty Cobb, 5 (1909–1913)
Ty Cobb, 3 (1917–1919)
Rod Carew, 3 (1973–1975)
NL
Dan Brouthers, 6 (1881–1886)
Rogers Hornsby, 6 (1920–1925)
Barry Bonds, 4 (2001–2004)
Honus Wagner, 3 (1907–1909)
Chuck Klein, 3 (1931–1933)
Johnny Mize, 3 (1938–1940)
Frank Robinson, 3 (1960–1962)
Willie McCovey, 3 (1968–1970)
Mike Schmidt, 3 (1980–1982)
AL
Babe Ruth, 7 (1918–1924)
Ty Cobb, 6 (1907–1912)
Babe Ruth, 6 (1926–1931)
Ted Williams, 4 (1946–1949)
NL
Honus Wagner, 4 (1906–1909)
Chuck Klein, 4 (1930–1933)
Rogers Hornsby, 3 (1920–1922)
Joe Medwick, 3 (1935–1937)
Johnny Mize, 3 (1938–1940)
Hank Aaron, 3 (1959–1961)
AL
Ty Cobb, 3 (1907–1909)
Jim Rice, 3 (1977–1979)
NL
Ginger Beaumont, 3 (1902–1904)
Rogers Hornsby, 3 (1920–1922)
Frank McCormick, 3 (1938–1940)
AL
Ichiro Suzuki, 5 (2006–2010)
Ty Cobb, 3 (1907–1909)
Johnny Pesky, 3 (1942, 1946–1947) (military service 1943–45)
Tony Oliva, 3 (1964–1966)
Kirby Puckett, 3 (1987–1989)
NL
Honus Wagner, 4 (1906–1909)
Dan Brouthers, 3 (1886–1888)
Rogers Hornsby, 3 (1920–1922)
Joe Medwick, 3 (1936–1938)
Stan Musial, 3 (1952–1954)
Pete Rose, 3 (1974–1976)
AL
Tris Speaker, 4 (1920–1923)
Don Mattingly, 3 (1984–1986)
NL
Garry Templeton, 3 (1977–1979)
AL
Elmer Flick, 3 (1905–1907)
Sam Crawford, 3 (1913–1915)
Zoilo Versalles, 3 (1963–1965)
Lance Johnson, 3 (1992–1994)
Carl Crawford, 3 (2004–2006)
NL
Cap Anson, 3 (1880–1882)
Cap Anson, 3 (1884–1886)
Rogers Hornsby, 3 (1920–1922)
Joe Medwick, 3 (1936–1938)
George Foster, 3 (1976–1978)
AL
Ty Cobb, 3 (1907–1909)
Babe Ruth, 3 (1919–1921)
Cecil Fielder, 3 (1990–1992)
AA
Harry Stovey, 3 (1883–1885)
NL
King Kelly, 3 (1884–1886)
Chuck Klein, 3 (1930–1932)
Duke Snider, 3 (1953–1955)
Pete Rose, 3 (1974–1976)
Albert Pujols, 3 (2003–2005)
AL
Ty Cobb, 3 (1909–1911)
Eddie Collins, 3 (1912–1914)
Babe Ruth, 3 (1919–1921)
Babe Ruth, 3 (1926–1928)
Ted Williams, 3 (1940–1942)
Mickey Mantle, 3 (1956–1958)
NL
Roy Thomas, 5 (1900–1904)
Barry Bonds, 5 (2000–2004)
Billy Hamilton, 4 (1894–1897)
Barry Bonds, 4 (1994–1997)
George Burns, 3 (1919–1921)
Mel Ott, 3 (1930–1932)
Arky Vaughan, 3 (1934–1936)
Eddie Mathews, 3 (1961–1963)
Ron Santo, 3 (1966–1968)
Mike Schmidt, 3 (1981–1983)
AL
Donie Bush, 4 (1909–1912)
Babe Ruth, 4 (1930–1933)
Ted Williams, 4 (1946–1949)
Babe Ruth, 3 (1926–1928)
Lou Gehrig, 3 (1935–1937)
NL
Rogers Hornsby, 6 (1920–1925)
Barry Bonds, 4 (2001–2004)
Joey Votto, 4 (2010–2013)
Honus Wagner, 3 (1907–1909)
Arky Vaughan, 3 (1934–1936)
Elbie Fletcher, 3 (1940–1942)
Joe Morgan, 3 (1974–1976)
Mike Schmidt, 3 (1981–1983)
Barry Bonds, 3 (1991–1993)
AL
Wade Boggs, 5 (1985–1989)
Lou Gehrig, 4 (1934–1937)
Ted Williams, 4 (1946–1949)
Ty Cobb, 3 (1913–1915)
Babe Ruth, 3 (1919–1921)
Babe Ruth, 3 (1930–1932)
Ted Williams, 3 (1940–1942)
Ted Williams, 3 (1956–1958)
NL
Maury Wills, 6 (1960–1965)
Vince Coleman, 6 (1985–1990)
Bob Bescher, 4 (1909–1912)
Max Carey, 4 (1915–1918)
Max Carey, 4 (1922–1925)
Willie Mays, 4 (1956–1959)
Lou Brock, 4 (1966–1969)
Lou Brock, 4 (1971–1974)
Tim Raines, 4 (1981–1984)
Kiki Cuyler, 3 (1928–1930)
Bill Bruton, 3 (1953–1955)
Tony Womack, 3 (1997–1999)
José Reyes, 3 (2005–2007)
Michael Bourn, 3 (2009–2011)
AL
Luis Aparicio, 9 (1956–1964)
Rickey Henderson, 7 (1980–1986)
Kenny Lofton, 5 (1992–1996)
George Case, 5 (1939–1943)
Bert Campaneris, 4 (1965–1968)
Rickey Henderson, 4 (1988–1991)
Ty Cobb, 3 (1915–1917)
Ben Chapman, 3 (1931–1933)
Bob Dillinger, 3 (1947–1949)
Minnie Miñoso, 3 (1951–1953)
NL
Sparky Adams, 3 (1925–1927)
Dave Cash, 3 (1974–1976)
AL
Ichiro Suzuki, 5 (2004–2008)
Doc Cramer, 3 (1933–1935)
Doc Cramer, 3 (1940–1942)
Bobby Richardson, 3 (1962–1964)
NL
Hack Wilson, 4 (1927–1930)
Vince DiMaggio, 4 (1942–1945)
Juan Samuel, 4 (1984–1987)
Pud Galvin, 3 (1879–1881)
Mike Schmidt, 3 (1974–1976)
Andrés Galarraga, 3 (1988–1990)
Sammy Sosa, 3 (1997–1999)
Adam Dunn, 3 (2004–2006)
Mark Reynolds, 3 (2008–2010)
AL
Reggie Jackson, 4 (1968–1971)
Jimmie Foxx, 3 (1929–1931)
Pat Seerey, 3 (1944–1946)
Jim Lemon, 3 (1956–1958)
Mickey Mantle, 3 (1958–1960)
Bobby Darwin, 3 (1972–1974)
Jack Cust, 3 (2007–2009)
MLB
Mark Reynolds, 4 (2008–2011)
Adam Dunn, 3 (2004–2006)
NL
Sandy Koufax, 5 (1962–1966)
Clayton Kershaw, 4 (2011–2014)
Greg Maddux, 3 (1993–1995)
AL
Lefty Grove, 4 (1929–1932)
Roger Clemens, 3 (1990–1992)
MLB
Clayton Kershaw, 4 (2011–2014)
Greg Maddux, 3 (1993–1995)
NL
Warren Spahn, 5 (1957–1961)
Pete Alexander, 4 (1914–1917)
Robin Roberts, 4 (1952–1955)
Bill Hutchinson, 3 (1890–1892)
Kid Nichols, 3 (1896–1898)
Tom Glavine, 3 (1991–1993)
AL
Walter Johnson, 4 (1913–1916)
Cy Young, 3 (1901–1903)
Bob Feller, 3 (1939–1941)
Hal Newhouser, 3 (1944–1946)
MLB
Robin Roberts, 4 (1952–1955)
Kid Nichols, 3 (1896–1898)
Pete Alexander, 3 (1915–1917)
Hal Newhouser, 3 (1944–1946)
NL
Joe McGinnity, 5 (1903–1907)
Bill Hutchinson, 3 (1890–1892)
Ace Adams, 3 (1942–1944)
Steve Kline, 3 (1999–2001)
Pedro Feliciano, 3 (2008–2010)
AL
Firpo Marberry, 3 (1924–1926)
Wilbur Wood, 3 (1968–1970)
MLB
Firpo Marberry, 3 (1924–1926)
Ace Adams, 3 (1942–1944)
Steve Kline, 3 (1999–2001)
Different leagues
Paul Quantrill, 4 (2001 (AL), 2002–2003 (NL), 2004 (AL))
NL
Mordecai Brown, 4 (1908–1911)
Bruce Sutter, 4 (1979–1982)
AL
Dan Quisenberry, 4 (1982–1985)
Firpo Marberry, 3 (1924–1926)
MLB
Firpo Marberry, 3 (1924–1926)
NL
Robin Roberts, 5 (1951–1955)
Greg Maddux, 5 (1991–1995)
Pete Alexander, 4 (1914–1917)
John Clarkson, 3 (1887–1889)
Bill Hutchinson, 3 (1890–1892)
Bucky Walters, 3 (1939–1941)
Phil Niekro, 3 (1977–1979)
Orel Hershiser, 3 (1987–1989)
Liván Hernández, 3 (2003–2005)
AL
Walter Johnson, 4 (1913–1916)
Wes Ferrell, 3 (1935–1937)
Bob Feller, 3 (1939–1941)
Jim Palmer, 3 (1976–1978)
MLB
Robin Roberts, 5 (1951–1955)
Pete Alexander, 3 (1915–1917)
Phil Niekro, 3 (1977–1979)
NL
Dazzy Vance, 7 (1922–1928)
Pete Alexander, 4 (1914–1917)
Dizzy Dean, 4 (1932–1935)
Warren Spahn, 4 (1949–1952)
Randy Johnson, 4 (1999–2002)
Amos Rusie, 3 (1893–1896)
Noodles Hahn, 3 (1899–1901)
Christy Mathewson, 3 (1903–1905)
Johnny Vander Meer, 3 (1941–1943)
Tim Lincecum, 3 (2008–2010)
AL
Walter Johnson, 8 (1912–1919)
Lefty Grove, 7 (1925–1931)
Rube Waddell, 6 (1902–1907)
Bob Feller, 4 (1938–1941)
Nolan Ryan, 4 (1976–1979)
Randy Johnson, 4 (1992–1995)
Bob Feller, 3 (1946–1948)
Camilo Pascual, 3 (1961–1963)
Sam McDowell, 3 (1968–1970)
Nolan Ryan, 3 (1972–1974)
Roger Clemens, 3 (1996–1998)
Johan Santana, 3 (2004–2006)
MLB
Rube Waddell, 5 (1903–1907)
Randy Johnson, 5 (1998–2002)
Dizzy Dean, 4 (1932–1935)
Bob Feller, 4 (1938–1941)
Walter Johnson, 3 (1912–1914)
Dazzy Vance, 3 (1923–1925)
Bob Feller, 3 (1946–1948)
Warren Spahn, 3 (1950–1952)
Sam McDowell, 3 (1968–1970)
Nolan Ryan, 3 (1972–1974)
Randy Johnson, 3 (1993–1995)
NL
Robin Roberts, 5 (1951–1955)
Don Drysdale, 4 (1962–1965)
Phil Niekro, 4 (1977–1980)
Greg Maddux, 4 (1990–1993)
Tom Glavine, 4 (1999–2002)
Bill Hutchinson, 3 (1890–1892)
Bob Friend, 3 (1956–1958)
Tom Browning, 3 (1988–1990)
AL
Bobo Newsom, 4 (1936–1939)
Wilbur Wood, 4 (1972–1975)
Dave Stewart, 4 (1988–1991)
Bob Feller, 3 (1946–1948)
Mike Moore, 3 (1992–1994)
MLB
Robin Roberts, 5 (1951–1955)
Bobo Newsom, 4 (1936–1939)
Don Drysdale, 4 (1962–1965)
Wilbur Wood, 4 (1972–1975)
Phil Niekro, 4 (1977–1980)
Tom Glavine, 4 (1999–2002)
Bob Feller, 3 (1946–1948)
Bob Friend, 3 (1956–1958)
NL
Tommy Bond, 3 (1877–1879)
Pete Alexander, 3 (1915–1917)
AA
Will White, 3 (1882–1884)
AL
Roger Clemens, 3 (1990–1992)
NL
Warren Spahn, 7 (1957–1963)
Robin Roberts, 5 (1952–1956)
Pete Alexander, 4 (1914–1917)
Jim McCormick, 3 (1880–1882)
Bill Hutchinson, 3(1890–1892)
Bucky Walters, 3 (1939–1941)
Phil Niekro, 3 (1977–1979)
Greg Maddux, 3 (1993–1995)
AL
Walter Johnson, 4 (1913–1916)
Lefty Grove, 3 (1931–1933)
Wes Ferrell, 3 (1935–1937)
Billy Pierce, 3 (1956–1958)
Roy Halladay, 3 (2007–2009)
MLB
Robin Roberts, 5 (1952–1956)
Warren Spahn, 4 (1957–1960)
Wes Ferrell, 3 (1935–1937)
NL
Amos Rusie, 5 (1890–1894)
Jimmy Ring, 4 (1922–1925)
Mickey Welch, 3 (1884–1886)
Cy Seymour, 3 (1897–1899)
Togie Pittinger, 3 (1902–1904)
AL
George Mullin, 4 (1903–1906)
Tommy Byrne, 3 (1949–1951)
Nolan Ryan, 3 (1972–1974)
Nolan Ryan, 3 (1976–1978)
Randy Johnson, 3 (1990–1992)
MLB
Togie Pittinger, 3 (1902–1904)
Tommy Byrne, 3 (1949–1951)
Nolan Ryan, 3 (1972–1974)
Nolan Ryan, 3 (1976–1978)
Randy Johnson, 3 (1990–1992)
NL
Phil Niekro, 4 (1977–1980)
Murry Dickson, 3 (1952–1954)
AL
Pedro Ramos, 4 (1958–1961)