Like Flies on Sherbert

Recording

The songs on the album were either Chilton originals or obscure cover versions of songs by artists including KC and the Sunshine Band, The Bell Notes, Ernest Tubb and the Carter Family. Critic Robert Christgau described them as a "bag of wrecked covers and discarded originals". All were recorded with false starts and vocal and musical errors, either created by accident or on purpose. Producer Jim Dickinson later described the recording of "No More the Moon Shines on Lorena": "Sometimes there was somebody in the control room and a lot of times there was nobody there. The beginning of 'Lorena' where it's spoken, that was overdubbed because whoever started the machine didn’t start it soon enough." The musicians also sometimes used instruments that were not fully functioning, as Dickinson explained: "The Minimoog was sitting around broken at [the studio]. I played it and all I did was twist knobs."

Chilton later said that when the recording sessions began, he began to think, "'Man these guys don't know the songs...this must sound terrible'. But when I went in the control room and heard what we’d been doing, it was just incredible sounding. Getting involved with Dickinson opened up a new world for me. Before that I'd been into careful layerings of guitars and voices and harmonies and things like that, and Dickinson showed me how to go into the studio and just create a wild mess and make it sound really crazy and anarchic. That was a growth for me."

Dickinson affirmed that Chilton consciously wanted the musicianship to be sloppy. He clarified that he plays guitar on the album despite not being technically proficient: "A lot of the guitar on Sherbert is me. Alex said, 'You still play like you’re 14 years old.' I said, 'Yeah, I play bad.' That's what he wanted."

Years later, for Robert Gordon's book on the Memphis music scene, "It Came from Memphis", Chilton stated, "My life was on the skids, and 'Like Flies on Sherbert' was a summation of that period. I like that record a lot. It's crazy but it’s a positive statement about a period in my life that wasn’t positive."

Critical reception

With its deliberately below-par sound quality and performances, reviews of Like Flies on Sherbert differ as to whether the effect is positive or merely substandard. Allmusic's David Cleary noted that "sound quality is terrible, instrumental balances are careless and haphazard, and some selections even begin with recording start-up sound." and described the album as "universally slipshod and boorish...sloppy and lackluster."

Another Allmusic critic, Stephen Thomas Erlewine, claimed the album was "a front-runner for the worst album ever made."

However, Rolling Stone's Ken Tucker described the album as "a small masterpiece of crudity and split-second invention", adding that "Chilton achieves his most startling, moving effects at precisely those moments when he seems least in control." Critic Robert Christgau was also positive towards the album, giving it a "B" rating and stating that "this long-time advertisement for self-abuse doesn't prove craziness is universal. Just makes you forget that things most certainly wouldn't be more fun if it was."

It also received positive reviews in Sounds and was a featured release in Creem.

Side 1

1. "Baron of Love, Pt. II" (Ross Johnson) – 4:11
2. "Girl After Girl" (Gary Shelton) – 2:28
3. "My Rival" (Alex Chilton) – 3:27
4. "No More the Moon Shines on Lorena" (A. P. Carter) – 4:35
5. "I've Had It" (Ray Ceroni, Carl Bonura) – 2:23

Side 2

1. "Rock Hard" (Chilton) – 2:42
2. "Waltz Across Texas" (Ernest Tubb) – 4:46
3. "Alligator Man" (Floyd Chance, Jimmy C. Newman) – 2:40
4. "Hey! Little Child" (Chilton) – 3:43
5. "Hook or Crook" (Chilton) – 2:25
6. "Like Flies on Sherbert" (Chilton) – 2:08

Side 1

1. "Boogie Shoes" (Harry Wayne Casey, Richard Finch) – 2:29
2. "My Rival" – 3:27
3. "Hey! Little Child" – 3:43
4. "Hook or Crook" – 2:25
5. "I've Had It" – 2:23

Side 2

1. "Rock Hard" – 2:42
2. "Girl After Girl" – 2:28
3. "Waltz Across Texas" – 4:46
4. "Alligator Man" – 2:40
5. "Like Flies on Sherbert" – 2:08

CD re-release

1. "Baron of Love" (Ross Johnson) – 4:11
2. "Girl After Girl"
3. "My Rival"
4. "No More the Moon Shines on Lorena"
5. "I've Had It"
6. "Rock Hard"
7. "Waltz Across Texas"
8. "Alligator Man"
9. "Hey! Little Child"
10. "Hook or Crook"
11. "Like Flies on Sherbert"
12. "Boogie Shoes"
13. "Baby Doll" (Chilton) – 2:51
14. "She's the One That's Got It" (Allen Page) – 1:54
15. "Stranded on a Dateless Night" (Cordell Jackson) – 2:33

Personnel