A-side "Terraplane Blues" Format 78 rpm record Length 2:52 | Released March 1937 (1937-03) Genre Blues | |
Recorded November 23, 1936,
San Antonio, Texas | ||
"Kind Hearted Woman Blues" is a blues song recorded on November 23, 1936 in San Antonio, Texas, by legendary bluesman Robert Johnson. The song was originally released on 78 rpm format as Vocalion 03416 and ARC 7-03-56. Johnson performed the song in the key of A, and recorded two takes, the first of which contains his only recorded guitar solo. Both takes were used for different pressings of both the Vocalion issue and the ARC issue. The first take (SA-2580-1) can be found on many compilation albums, including the first one, King of the Delta Blues Singers (1961). Take 2 (SA-2580-2) can be heard on the later compilation Robert Johnson, The Complete Recordings (1990).
Contents
Influences
This was the first song that Johnson recorded, and it was carefully crafted in imitation of recent hit records. It was composed as if in answer to "Cruel Hearted Woman Blues" by Bumble Bee Slim (Amos Easton), which in turn was based on "Mean Mistreater Mama" by Leroy Carr accompanied by Scrapper Blackwell. Johnson uses the Carr melody and conveys something of Carr's style in his relaxed singing. His guitar accompaniment echoes Carr's piano phrases in the first verse, then copies Blackwell's guitar phrases in the second verse. He then adds a musical bridge in the style of another hit record, "Milk Cow Blues" by Kokomo Arnold. At the end of the bridge, he jumps into a higher register as Arnold does, but then maintains an extraordinary controlled falsetto, which may have been based on the singing of Joe Pullum. Thus Johnson showed in his very first recording that he had mastered the commercially successful urban blues style of the Thirties. However, his debut cannot be dismissed as derivative. He combined elements of the styles of others into a highly individual style of his own.
Like Bumble Bee Slim, Johnson wrote lyrics consisting mostly of conventional twelve-bar three-line verses, but varied with an eight-bar bridge. Slim's bridge merely repeated the words, but Johnson wrote a more complex sequence:
Johnson also makes a marked change in tone. Leroy Carr's original "Mean Mistreating Mama" was resigned, even understanding:
You're a mean mistreating mama, and you don't mean me no good
And I don't blame you baby, I'd be the same way if I could
Bumble Bee Slim removed that hint of sympathy when he covered the song as "Mean Mistreatin' Woman":
You's a mean mistreatin' woman, but I love you just the same
I know you didn't want me, the day I changed your name
When he wrote new words to the tune, his mood was still resigned:
You's a cruel heated woman, swear, and you just can't realise
That's all right baby, I'll be the same when I rise
Johnson decides that his "kind-hearted woman" is, after all, hostile. But there is no resignation, only anguish:
I love my baby, my baby don't love me
And I really love that woman, can't stand to let her be
She's a kind-hearted woman, she studies evil all the time
You wells to kill me, as to have it on your mind
Other versions
Like many of Johnson's songs, "Kind Hearted Woman Blues" is a staple in the repertoires of many blues musicians and has been recorded by dozens of traditional and contemporary blues figures, including Muddy Waters, Robert Lockwood, Jr., Johnny Winter, David Bromberg, George Thorogood, and Keb' Mo'. It was included on Eric Clapton's 2004 album, Me and Mr. Johnson, along with many other Johnson classics.
The Youngbloods recorded a version of the song and it was released as a B-side on two singles: "Dreamboat" in 1972 and "Running Bear" in 1972.
On Led Zeppelin's cover of Johnson's "Traveling Riverside Blues", singer Robert Plant quotes this song with the line: "Got a kind-hearted woman/she studies evil all the time".
According to Stephen Calt, the phrase kind-hearted woman was slang for a woman who "catered to a gigolo in return for sexual fidelity".