It Was Him or Us

Plot

One night in a small town, Peggy Wilson and her daughter Carrie get up and leave Peggy's abusive husband and Carrie's father, Buddy. As they try to leave, Buddy comes to the pickup begging Peggy to forgive him and asking Carrie to open the door. Unmoved by his pleas, Peggy points a gun at Buddy, telling him to stay away from her and Carrie as she drives away.

Eighteen years later, Peggy is now living in Salt Lake City with her new husband, Walter Pomeroy, with whom she has 2 sons, Jesse and Stevie. Her daughter Carrie, now a single mother to a 5-year-old girl named Jenna, is living with them and complains about not having a boyfriend or husband. Carrie then goes to apply for a job in an office at a construction site, where she meets good-looking young construction worker Gene Shepard, who asks her out. When he comes to pick Carrie up for their first date, the family seems to approve of him because of his kindness, but Peggy makes the comment that she wished Gene had called first, to which Carrie tells her mom to be nice as she leaves with Gene. During their date at a pizza restaurant, the two end up making love in the bathroom, claiming they were meant for each other.

A few days later, Carrie invites Gene to a party at a bar with her friends, but Gene says no because he doesn't want to "hang out with losers", so Carrie goes to the party alone. While there, she dances with a friend of hers named Scottie, but Gene (who had secretly followed Carrie to the bar) appears and beats up Scottie in a violent rage, resulting in the bar manager kicking Gene out. Later, when Carrie tries to go into her house, Gene violently pulls her away from the house and yells at her until Peggy comes out and tells Gene to leave Carrie alone. Gene then leaves, running over their mailbox with his car, and Carrie blames her mom for trying to help.

The next day Gene's mom Maggie comes over and asks Carrie to come have lunch with Gene and her at their house, which she does. While there, Gene apologizes for getting violent and promises to someday marry her and buy a house for her, him, and Jenna; but when Gene goes to work later he learns that his boss has fired him because Peggy found out that Gene had a history of violence and reported it to his boss. Gene and Carrie go to Peggy's house, where Gene expresses his anger about getting fired, while Carrie calls her mom crazy and blames her for getting Gene fired. As a result, Carrie decides that she and Jenna are going to move in with Gene and his mother.

Three months later, Gene, Carrie and Jenna meet Peggy and Walter and the boys in the park to have a picnic, which initially seems to go well, but when Carrie and Peggy take Jenna to a merry-go-round, Gene tries to call Carrie but she doesn't hear him. When they return home later that night, he takes his anger out on Carrie, accusing her of trying to ignore him at the park and throwing things around the house. Carrie grabs Jenna and leaves, but as she and Jenna get in the car, Gene comes out with a baseball bat and smashes the windshield. The police come and take Gene to jail, and Walter and Peggy show up; Peggy tells Maggie her son is sick, and runs into the house and embraces Carrie and Jenna. The next day, Carrie visits Gene in jail and tells him she won't see him anymore. However, during a Saturday visit to the mall with Scottie, she appears to be having second thoughts about leaving Gene, despite Scottie's attempts to convince her otherwise. Suddenly, Gene appears (having been released on bail), and violently attacks Scottie. Now realizing her mom was right all along, Carrie tells Gene to leave her alone, and warns him that she can put him in jail for a very long time.

On Sunday Carrie receives a call from Gene asking her to forgive him, but she lies to Gene, saying that she is seeing somebody else and that the person is coming over to meet her. Enraged, Gene grabs a gun and goes to the house, telling Peggy that he's there to kill her, Carrie, Walter, Jenna, Stevie, and Jesse. He then hears Carrie downstairs on the phone with Scottie and rushes down to orders her upstairs, while Jesse and Stevie manage to hide in an air vent downstairs and find a secret exit from a wooded window. They soon notice their dad returning home from a hunting trip and they try to warn him, but he doesn't hear them and enters the house and is also taken hostage by Gene. However, the boys are found by Scottie, who frees them and takes them to the police. When the police arrive at the house, Lt. Washington asks the boys about what happened, so the boys tell her about their sister's boyfriend coming in with a gun threatening to kill everyone. Gene then appears at the door and the police draw their guns, but Gene puts Jenna down and returns inside the house while Jenna walks safely to the police and her uncles.

As night falls, the police try to do everything to get Gene to cooperate with them, even bringing his mom to the house to talk to him, but nothing works. At one point, Walter tries to stop Gene by hiding in the bedroom closet and jumping onto him from behind, but in the ensuing struggle, Gene knocks him out cold with his gun. While Gene grabs Carrie and begins to talk to her, telling her how much he loves her, Peggy sneaks into the basement and talks to Lt. Washington, who tells her to try to sneak out the exit her sons did, but Peggy tells her that she won't leave her daughter alone. She sneaks into her room, grabs Walter's gun and points it at Gene, firing and killing him. As the sun rises, Peggy and Carrie walk out of the house while the police bring out the bodies of Walter and Gene. Lt. Washington then tells Peggy that Walter will be all right, adding that she could have lost her life while in there, to which Peggy replies "When it comes to your kids, you have to do what you have to do". She then returns to her children and granddaughter, and the film ends.

Cast