Citations 182 U.S. 1 (more) End date 1901 | Dissent Gray | |
Full case name Elias S.A. DeLima, et al., plaintiffs in error, v. George R. Bidwell Majority Brown, joined by Fuller, Harlan, Peckham, Brewer Dissent McKenna, joined by Shiras, White Ruling court Supreme Court of the United States Similar Insular Cases, Reid v Covert, Boumediene v Bush, Pollock v Farmers' Loan & Tr, United States v E C Knight | ||
DeLima v. Bidwell, 182 U.S. 1 (1901), was one of a group of the first Insular Cases decided by the US Supreme Court.
Contents
The case was argued on January 8-11, 1901 and was decided on May 27, 1901.
Background
The DeLima Sugar Importing Company sued the New York City collector of customs to recover duties on sugar imported from Puerto Rico after 1899, when Puerto Rico was ceded to the United States. DeLima argued that The Port of New York City had no jurisdiction to collect duties since Puerto Rico had been annexed by the United States.
The lower appellate court held the following:
- Although the collector had the right to challenge the factual sufficiency, he was barred from challenging federal jurisdiction on the basis of wrongful removal where the case was removed upon his own petition.
- The Customs Administrative Act did not decide whether the sugar was imported from a foreign country so the court case was a proper legal action.
- Puerto Rico was not a foreign country for tariff purposes but was a United States territory because, by treaty, the district was ceded to and in the possession of the United States. It was not necessary for an act of Congress to embrace the territory for the purpose of tariff laws. Therefore, the duties on sugar were illegal, and DeLima Sugar Importing Company was entitled to get its duties on sugar back.
Decision
The Supreme Court ruled 5-4 that Puerto Rico, since its cession to the United States in 1898 following the Treaty of Paris, was not a foreign country for purposes of the tariff laws of the United States, which required payment of duties on goods moving into the United States from a foreign country. In the absence of congressional legislation, the US government could not collect customs duties on sugar from Puerto Rico shipped to other parts of the United States by classifying Puerto Rico as a foreign country.
The majority opinion was authored by Justice Henry Billings Brown, joined by Justices Melville Fuller, John Marshall Harlan, Rufus Wheeler Peckham and David Josiah Brewer. Justice Joseph McKenna authored a dissent, which was joined by Justices George Shiras, Jr., and Edward Douglass White. Justice Horace Gray authored a separate dissenting opinion.
The decision is similar to Downes v. Bidwell, 182 U.S. 244 (1901), decided on the same date.