Cecil Brown (Hawaii politician)

Background

Brown was born in Wailua, Hawaii to Thomas and Mary Ann (Rhodes) Brown who moved to the Hawaiian Islands from England in 1844. He was the fifth of six siblings (who survived infancy), two of whom were also involved in Hawaiian politics: Godfrey (Minister of Foreign Affairs, then Minister of Finance for the Kingdom of Hawaii) and Frank (House of Representatives, Kingdom of Hawaii). Brown married Mary K. Miner Dickson (widow of Menzies Dickson) on August 11, 1897. They had no children together. She died on September 12, 1907.

Family

Thomas and Mary Ann (Rhodes) Brown had four children (Arthur, Godfrey, Alice, and Frank) before leaving England for the warmer climate of the Hawaiian Islands in 1844. Louis (died in infancy), Cecil, and Malcolm were born in Hawaii. In 1853 the entire family left for Boston to put Arthur, Godfrey, and Frank in school. The remaining members of the Brown family returned to Hawaii at the very end of 1855.

Early life

Cecil was homeschooled by his parents and educated by his maternal aunt Sarah Rhodes Von Pfister. He attended the Cathedral Grammar School followed by the Punahou School. In December 1866 Brown left Honolulu for the United States, and enrolled in Columbia Law School (Washington D.C.). He graduated with honors in June 1871, and moved to New York City (1871–74) where he was employed by the law firm of Evarts, Southmayd, and Choate. In 1874 Brown moved to San Francisco before returning to Honolulu.

Shortly after his return to Hawaii, Brown was licensed to practice law before the Supreme Court of the Kingdom of Hawaii on January 28, 1875. He was appointed a notary public for Oahu on July 27, 1875 by King Kalākaua. Starting a private practice, he was representing clients in circuit court by the end of 1875, and in the Supreme Court of the Kingdom of Hawaii by 1876. Despite his future political and business careers, Brown continued the private practice of law (mainly probate) for the duration of his life. On at least eight occasions between 1893 and 1901, Brown sat on the bench of the Supreme Court of Hawaii as an Acting Justice.

Political career

Cecil Brown’s political career spanned nearly 40 years (1876–1913). He was engaged in politics under four constitutions of the Kingdom of Hawaii prior to annexation by the United States: 1840, 1852, 1864, and 1887, and a constitution for the Republic of Hawaii (of which Brown was one of the framers) that was adopted on July 4, 1894. The last three constitutions (1864, 1887, and 1894) were each in effect at some point during Cecil Brown’s career in public service.

Kingdom of Hawaii

On September 5, 1876, Representative Samuel Kamakau died in office. A special election to fill the remainder of his term was held September 18, 1876 and Brown was elected. His bid for re-election in February 1878 was close but unsuccessful.

In July 1878 Brown was appointed the clerk to the Attorney General and by November of the same year legal announcements published in the local newspapers referenced him as the Deputy Attorney General. He was listed in the Kingdom’s directory for 1880 as Deputy Attorney General, the first use of the title in an official directory.

Brown carried several government appointments. In addition to notary public, he was appointed in 1877 to a three-person Board of Appraisers of Lands, and in 1879 as an Agent to Take Acknowledgments to Instruments. He would later resign all three appointments in 1887, to be in compliance with the 1887 Constitution of the Kingdom of Hawaii.

In February 1884, Cecil Brown (along with brothers Godfrey and Frank) were elected to the Legislative Assembly’s House of Representatives. Cecil proposed, passed, and had signed into law the first bill of the legislative session, named the "Turkey Law". Brown was re-elected in 1886, 1888 and appointed Chair of the Judiciary Committee, and 1890.

While planning to run for a vacant seat in the House of Nobles, Brown was appointed Attorney General of the Kingdom of Hawaii in the newly formed cabinet of Queen Liliuokalani in November 1892. The cabinet was disbanded on January 12, 1893 and on January 17 a coup d'état resulted in the overthrow of the Kingdom of Hawaii.

Provisional Government of Hawaii

The Provisional Government of Hawaii established an Advisory Council vested with legislative powers. Brown was appointed on January 25, 1893 after declining an appointment as Attorney General, made on January 16, the evening before the overthrow. On March 20, 1893 he was appointed Commissioner of a three-person committee tasked with the revision of the Hawaiian penal code, and was appointed chair of the Judiciary Committee. An act calling for a constitutional convention (to which Brown was a delegate) was passed on March 15, 1894 and convened from May 30 to July 3, 1894. Brown was one of the signers of the 1894 constitution of the newly formed Republic of Hawaii.

Republic of Hawaii

Brown resigned from the Advisory Council on October 25, 1894 to run for the Senate. He was elected in November 1894 and served continuously through 1904. During his tenure in the Senate, Brown served on the Council of State from June 23, 1895 through 1901, and on the Senate Judiciary, Coinage, and Foreign Relations committees. In November 1904, though nominated, Brown was not re-elected. There was talk of Brown running again in the general elections of 1906 and 1908, but in 1910 he was re-elected. Cecil Brown effectively retired from the Senate in May 1914.

Boards of directors

Cecil Brown sat on multiple association and business boards as trustee, director, or officer. Beginning in the early 1880s, Brown was a director of the Stock Breeders’ Association, and Treasurer of the Kapiolani Park Association, and the Hawaiian Jockey Club.

Business interests included the Hawaiian Hardware Company (Vice-President), Honolulu Soap Works company, Ltd. (President), the California Feed Company, Ltd. (President), and the Hawaiian Fibre Company, Limited (President). Sugar interests included the Kona Sugar Company, Ookala Sugar Plantation Co., and Pacific Sugar Mill (Vice-president).

Telephone service in Hawaii

Hawaiian Bell Telephone Company (HBT) incorporated in 1879, and began service on December 30, 1880. In August 1883, Mutual Telephone Company was founded as a competitor and began operations in March 1885. On August 2, 1894 the two companies consolidated with Mutual Telephone in control.

Cecil and brother Godfrey were elected to the board of directors of HBT in early 1884 (Godfrey as Vice-President and Cecil as Auditor), and by the end of the year, Godfrey had become President. By January 1886, Godfrey was both President and Treasurer, and Cecil Vice-President, positions they would hold for the next several years.

In September 1892, Cecil was also elected to the board of directors of rival company Mutual Telephone. When the two companies merged in 1894, he was named Vice-President of Mutual Telephone Company, and two years later Godfrey was elected Treasurer. Cecil remained Vice-President for over a decade.

The First National Bank of Hawaii

Anticipating the annexation of Hawaii as a US territory (July 1898), and the expected adoption of the National Banking Act, by the beginning of 1898 several parties had already sent requests to Washington DC to reserve the title "The First National Bank of Hawaii". Brown served as attorney to George Macfarlane during the organization and incorporation of the First American Bank of Hawaii during 1899. The bank organizers anticipated that having a fully functioning bank in place when the National Banking Act was extended to include the Territory of Hawaii would allow them to then become The First National Bank of Hawaii. At the first stockholders meeting in September 1899, Cecil Brown was elected President.

Congress eventually extended the National Banking Act to include the Territory of Hawaii (April 30, 1900), and during a July 1900 stockholders meeting, it was agreed to convert the First American Bank into a national bank. The First National Bank of Hawaii at Honolulu opened for business on October 1, 1900. Brown remained President of the bank until 1915, when he stepped down and became chairman of the board.

Declining health and death

In the summer of 1914, while visiting San Francisco, Brown’s health began to deteriorate. After a two and a half month illness he was hospitalized when he suffered a "severe" stroke and was reported in "serious condition". He arrived in Hawaii on November 4, 1914 and suffered a second stroke on March 4, 1915, leaving his right side partially paralyzed. He was reported to be in "critical" condition. Although it was initially reported that Brown’s condition was slowly improving, by the end of 1916 his functioning had significantly deteriorated, and in late December 1916 the courts declared him to be "mentally non-competent", and appointed his nephew H.M. von Holt as his guardian. On March 6, 1917 Cecil Brown died of apoplexy. The following day the Territorial Senate, House, and Hawaiian Bar Association issued resolutions expressing condolences and loss.