Teenage Amy Fisher (Alyssa Milano) shoots and wounds the wife (Phyllis Lyons) of a man (Jack Scalia) she calls her lover.
Casualties of Love: The Long Island Lolita Story (1993) was the third made-for-television movie based on the story of Amy Fisher and Joey Buttafuoco, written and directed by John Herzfeld. Alyssa Milano and Jack Scalia played the main characters in this movie for CBS. The movie aired the same night and time as ABCs movie, though ABCs movie was much higher rated in the TV ratings and critically praised.
Phyllis Lyons, Leo Rossi, and Lawrence Tierney portrayed Buttafuocos relatives.
Joey Buttafuoco's story, of how a sexy, possessive young girl destroyed his life by telling her friends the two are lovers, and then shooting his wife.
Set on Long Island, the film opens with Joey Buttafuoco (Jack Scalia) driving under influence of cocaine, fleeing from the cops and visiting his mothers grave. At home, his wife Mary Jo (Phyllis Lyons) awaits his return, disappointed in his drug back lapse. After she threatens to leave him if he does not quit using drugs, Joey decides to enter rehab. Six weeks later, he is a renewed man, promising his wife he is now the person again she fell in love with. Three years later, in the summer of 1991, he works in an auto repair shop, and meets 17-year-old Amy Fisher (Alyssa Milano), who begs Joey to repair her car without telling her parents. Joey agrees, even though he is a close acquaintance of her father Elliot (Jack Kehler). Amy frequently crashes her car, prompting her to make multiple visits to Joey. It does not take long before she starts coming on to him, making hints of her promiscuous past despite her young age. Even though he does not respond to her affection, Joey does not especially push her away and constantly pays her special attention.
One day at the carnival with her friend Lizzy (Georgia Emelin), Amy notices Joey and surprises him with a kiss. Joey is startled and immediately leaves. After he is gone, Amy claims to Lizzy that she has been dating him for a while now. The next day, Joey finds out that Elliot has filed a complaint with the police after Amy has claimed that Joey gave her herpes. Joey sets out to the Fisher residence to set things straight, and Amy eventually admits that she lied about the situation. Joey is outraged, though does not inform his wife, fearing that it will affect their marriage. Later, at a cafe, Joey assures Amy that he has no interest in leaving his wife and children, and ignores her when she shows to him that she is wearing his car repair shop t-shirt. By now, Amy is madly in love with Joey and thinks that the only thing holding them apart is Mary Jo. She hires a contract killer to kill Mary Jo - paying him $600 and allowing him to sleep with her - though the young man eventually chickens out.
Six months later, she shows up at the Buttafuoco residence once again and claims to Mary Jo that Joey is having an affair with her "16-year-old sister", showing him Joeys car repair shop t-shirt to "prove" her claim. When Mary Jo refuses to believe her, Amy takes out her gun and shoots Mary Jo in the head. Later at the hospital, Joey is informed that his wifes situation is critical and that she might be paralyzed for the rest of her life, if she does not die. Amy, meanwhile, sets out to her boyfriend Paul (Michael Bowen), who is in a relationship with another woman, for comfort. Back in the hospital, a severely injured Mary Jo informs Joey and the detectives that her attacker owned his repair shop t-shirt. Joey then realizes Amy shot Mary Jo. Following her arrest, Amy claims that she and Joey both conspired to kill Mary Jo, enabling them to spend their life together. Joey denies any of Amys claims, and swears to the cops that he was never involved with her. In the media, Joey is frequently mentioned as an adulterer and conspirer, causing even Mary Jo to question her husband.
Even though he is advised to not set out to the media, Joey decides to make an official report after the media releases a sex tape of Amy and an older man. It is claimed that Joey forced her into a life of prostitution, and that the older man of the tape was one of her clients. In prison, Amy continues to make love claims to Joey, now through letters. During the court case, Amys bail is set at $2 million, the highest in New York state history, and Joey is tarnished by reporters. He tries to stand by his wife, but Mary Jo is confused by all the "evidence" thats coming up in court, "proving" Joey is guilty. She blames him for not being able to protect her, though she does not leave him.
By August 1992, bail for Amy is made by a TV network working to adapt her story. Joeys life falls more apart when he is informed that the entire Buttafuoco family will lose the auto repair shop if it is proven that he had an affair with Amy (the pressure causes his father to have a heart attack). The Buttafuocos want to allow Amy to have a plea bargain, or else her attorney will destroy the family company. Even though Mary Jo objects to the situation, reminding her family that she is the victim here, Amy is allowed a deal in court: she will receive 5 to 15 years for "reckless assault". Pleas of "attempted murder" among others are dropped, so the D.A. can come after Joey Buttafuoco for statutory rape. Soon after, a video tape is released in which Amy brags about her plea, and asks Paul to marry her. The tape allows the Buttafuocos to clear their name, while Amy receives the maximum sentence of 15 years in prison.Jack Scalia - Joseph Joey Buttafuoco
Alyssa Milano - Amy Fisher
Phyllis Lyons - Mary Jo Buttafuoco
Leo Rossi - Bobby Buttafuoco
J.E. Freeman - Det. Marty Algar
Peter Van Norden - Joeys Attorney
Lawrence Tierney - Joey Buttafuccos Father
Michael Bowen - Paul Makely
Jack Kehler - Elliot Fisher
John Herzfeld directed Casualties of Love: The "Long Island Lolita" Story and The Preppie Murder. The Amy Fisher Story (1993). Cries Unheard: The Donna Yaklich Story (1994). Alyssa Milano appears in Casualties of Love: The "Long Island Lolita" Story and Wisegal. Having Our Say: The Delany Sisters First 100 Years (1999).
By the time the film was first aired, Casualties of Love received a fair share of media attention, due to the film being one of three about Amy Fisher and Joey Buttafuoco to be aired on the same night by three different TV networks. Filming took place in November and December 1992, and the film was promoted as the TV version that told Joey Buttafuocos side of the story. USA Network bought the films rights in 1992, and commented on the production: "This particular movie was very attractive. The topic is just so hot right now." Casualties of Love did not live up to a common television film budget of $2 million. Due to the popularity of its story, the film had a much higher budget.
The film was known for being Alyssa Milanos first "adult role" which shed her "nice girl image" she gained from appearing in Whos the Boss? from 1984 to 1992. The producers cast her after seeing her portrayal as a teenage prostitute in the independent film Where the Day Takes You (1992). Milano was very enthusiastic when she found out she got the role, saying: "Theres nothing grittier than playing Amy Fisher." On her character, Milano commented: "Our version was the one from Joey Buttafuocos point of view: That she was a lunatic. Since then, weve learned that his version wasnt all true. But it was really challenging to make her believable, because everybody had already seen her on TV and they knew what she looked like and how she moved. I think that movie was the least "Alyssa" of anything Ive done." Of all the three Amy Fisher films, Milano was glad that she was picked for Casualties of Love, because it was the one where Amy Fisher was portrayed the most as a "psycho", which allowed her to practice her acting skills.
The film was shot between November 23 and December 16, 1992.