Citation(s) [1975] 1 WLR 758 | Ruling court House of Lords | |
 | ||
Full case name British Eagle International Airlines Ltd v Compagnie Nationale Air France Similar National Provincial Bank v C, British India Steam Na, Re Brumark Investme, Aluminium Industrie Vaassen, Re Spectrum Plus Ltd | ||
British Eagle International Air Lines Ltd v Cie Nationale Air France [1975] 1 WLR 758 is a UK insolvency law case, concerning priority of creditors in a company winding up.
Contents
Facts
A number of airlines agreed to set up a clearing house to manage debt and credit accounts among themselves. Each airline in the group owed multiple and changing debts to one another, so to make settlements easier, participants were not meant to claim against one another, but simply enter their transactions in the clearing house, and then settle the balance at the end of each month. The clearing house fell under the authority of the International Air Transport Association, or IATA. British Eagle went insolvent, and owed money to the clearing house overall, but was a creditor to Air France. The liquidator attempted to recover the money from Air France and Air France argued it was bound by the clearing house scheme, and could only collect money after netting out the claims of creditors of British Eagle in IATA. So the liquidator challenged the legality of the scheme, as it purported to sidestep pari passu.
Judgment
The majority of the House of Lords (Lord Cross of Chelsea, Lord Diplock and Lord Edmund-Davies) held that the clearing house scheme could not put Air France in a better position than it would be, and could not have the effect of avoiding the insolvency priority rules, which would be against public policy. It was unlawful to attempt to contract out of (what is now) the Insolvency Act 1986 section 107. Therefore, the majority in the House of Lords ruled in favour of the liquidators of British Eagle.
Lord Cross gave the leading opinion.
Lord Morris of Borth-Y-Gest and Lord Simon of Glaisdale gave dissenting judgments.