Harman Patil (Editor)

Barber–Mizell feud

Updated on
Edit
Like
Comment
Share on FacebookTweet on TwitterShare on LinkedInShare on Reddit
Date
  
1870

Arrested
  
10

Death(s)
  
41

Location
  
Brevard and Orange counties in Florida

Causes
  
boundary dispute, cattle taxation, resentment over Reconstruction

Barber family, Yates family
  
Mizell family, Overstreet family

The Barber–Mizell feud was a feud in Brevard and Orange counties, Florida in 1870 resulting in 41 deaths and no criminal convictions that arose when cattle baron Mose Barber disputed the jurisdiction of Orange County Sheriff and tax collector David Mizell over his land. When Mizell rode to collect taxes from Barber, he was waylaid and killed. In the resultant feud, 41 men were killed.

Contents

Feud

Barber, a staunch Confederate supporter, did not want to pay taxes to the government and felt that Mizell—himself a Confederate veteran—was a carpetbagging traitor out to exploit his former comrades. As a result of the man's non-compliance, Mizell repeatedly took Barber's cattle as payment for taxes. Then on February 21, 1870, Barber—fed up at this point and having warned Mizell not to set foot on his land again—fatally shot the sheriff as he ventured into his property to take more cattle. Although the dying sheriff asked his family not to avenge his death, they nevertheless went on a revenge spree which was reciprocated by the Barbers and their supporters. Eight died, and no one was convicted for the murders. But the feud finally ended during the 1940s when a Barber married a Mizell.

These feud-related deaths were enumerated in the 1870 Mortality schedule of Orange County, Florida:

  • Isaac Barber, 35, white male, married, born in Georgia, shot in March.
  • Moses Barber, 37, white male, married, born in Georgia, Farmer, drowned in March.
  • William Bronson, 37, white male, married, farmer, born in South Carolina, shot in March.
  • David Mizell, Orange County Sheriff, 36, white male, married, born 12 Nov 1833 Columbia County Florida, shot from ambush 21 Feb 1870.
  • Needham Yates, 52, white male, married, born in Georgia, Farmer, shot in March.
  • William Yates, 32, white male, married, born in Georgia, Farmer, shot in March.
  • Needham Yates, Jr.

    • References

    Barber–Mizell feud Wikipedia
    (Text) CC BY-SA