Suddenly, Last Summer (Modern Family)

Plot

Gay marriage in California is now legal and Cam (Eric Stonestreet) and Mitch (Jesse Tyler Ferguson) are excited since now they can get married. They both start thinking if a proposal would be something that they should do now or wait. Cam asks Gloria (Sofía Vergara) for her advice/help and after she is telling him that he should propose to Mitch, Cam tries to find the perfect way to do it. Mitch has the same thoughts and he asks Claire (Julie Bowen) for help since being romantic is not something that comes easy to him. Claire's ideas though do not really help since she is even less romantic than he is, so he decides to do it his own way.

Cam takes Mitch to the restaurant where they had their first date and Mitch realizes immediately why Cam took him there. Mitch finds an excuse to leave and go back home since if Cam proposes, it will destroy his plans of proposing to Cam and being romantic for the first time. On their way back home, they get a flat tire and as they both kneel to change the tire, they just look at each other, share a smile, and say "yes" at the same time.

In the meantime, Claire and Phil (Ty Burrell) try to organize a kid-free week so they can be alone by coordinating Luke's (Nolan Gould) summer camp with Alex's (Ariel Winter) volunteering excursion and Haley's (Sarah Hyland) beach trip.

At the Delgado-Pritchett house, Manny (Rico Rodriguez) gets ready for his first solo trip to Colombia to see Gloria's family. Jay (Ed O'Neill) tries to make him get ready as fast as possible before Gloria changes her mind about sending him away.

Ratings

In its original American broadcast, "Suddenly, Last Summer" (that was aired along with the second episode of season five, First Days) was watched by 11.68 million. It was the least watched premiere out of all seasons; the Pilot was watched by 12.61 million, The Old Wagon was watched by 12.61 million, Dude Ranch was watched by 14.54 million and Bringing Up Baby was watched by 14.44 million. However, it was up by 1.67 million from the last episode, Goodnight Gracie of season four.

Reviews

"Suddenly, Last Summer" received generally positive reviews, with the critics being positive with Mitchell and Cameron's plot and the idea of the two characters getting married.

Joe Reid of The A.V. Club gave a 'B+' grade to the episode (along with First Days one) saying: ""Suddenly, Last Summer" is the classic Summer Vacation Episode that can either happen at the beginning or end of a season and kind of exists somewhere out of time."

Leigh Raines of TV Fanatic rated the two episodes with a 5/5 saying that both of the show's episodes were strong. "I laughed out loud a few times, got a little misty eyed at moments and did a combination of the two when Jay started crying at Manny's letter and wanted to mail him his second robe. Only the best shows can bring out that kind of dual reaction!"

Madina Papadopoulos from Paste Magazine rated the episode with 8.1/10 saying that the season is off to a great start. "The characters came off strong, the jokes hit, and there were tear-jerking moments at the end. [...] As usual, the characters are incredible, the writing is impeccable, and there is a sweetness to the show which elevates it above just a sitcom."

Matt LeMaire from The MacGuffin net rated both episodes with 8/10. "...that moment when they both knelt down to change the tire and both said yes was quite sweet and heartfelt–ultimately perfect for these characters. Truthfully, that scene couldn’t have been written better." It closes the review with: "As a premiere, both episodes did a good job of bringing us back into the world of Modern Family and while there were certainly some predictable elements, it’s our love of these characters that shines through as they navigate through their daily lives."

Emily Carlstrom from Better With Popcorn rated both episodes with 7.5/10. "...my favourite part of the episode was Clare’s ‘ghoulish’ scenarios for Mitch to use when proposing to Cam after the Supreme Court legalized gay marriage. Including Cam and Mitch’s reactions to this historic win was really important in grounding the current political climate in the real [realistic] lives of individuals."

Production

The premiere of this season of the series began with new opening credits, which Nolan Gould stated had been done because everyone had grown up so much. In the scene where Jay and Manny go to the court house to get Manny's birth certificate, the people who are standing outside the court house are crew members of the show, including the cast director of the show, Jeff Greenberg, and his partner Lars.