Naughty or Nice (2012 film)

Plot

Krissy Kringle (Hilarie Burton) is named after Santa Claus and lives on Candy Cane Lane. A real career woman, Krissy does not enjoy the Christmas season, partially due to the attention she receives because of her name. She has a steady job at a firm and hopes to marry her boyfriend Lance (Matt Dallas) sometime soon. Her life gets turned upside down when she is suddenly fired by her cold boss Helen (Michelle Hurd). That night, she visits her parents Walter (Michael Gross) and Carol (Meridith Baxter), who arrange for her a demeaning job as an elf in a gift-wrapping department of the local mall. There, she is put down by her boss Justin (Tony Cavalero), but quickly befriends her fellow elf Marco (Gabriel Tigerman).

One day, Krissy receives a package in her mail, and finds herself in the possession of Santa's naughty or nice book. By calling out their name, Krissy can now see in the book what naughty deeds people have done. Krissy first uses the book on Justin after being put down for the hundredth time, by revealing that he has stolen money from the company, and blackmailing him into allowing her more freedom. At home, she is bothered by her dominant neighbor Debbie, who is constantly at her lips for not decorating her house for the local competition. Through the book, Krissy finds out that Debbie has been stealing decorations from her neighbor, and reveals her seemingly true nature at the election, causing the neighborhood to turn on her.

Meanwhile, Krissy is having difficulty with her boyfriend constantly working late. Encouraged by Marco, she questions the book about Lance, and is told that he has had a one-night stand with Jill (Danneel Ackles), her former colleague and friend. Outraged, Krissy dumps her boyfriend and turns her anger to one of the children at the mall. This incident was filmed by bystanders and is put on YouTube, causing Krissy to become a media sensation. Devastated, Krissy turns to her parents and finds out that the book has two sides, and that she has only been focussing on the naughty-part. She finds out that Debbie has been donating a lot of money to good funds anonymously, Lance has not been cheating on her but had the fling with Jill while they were broken up in the past, and more importantly, that Jill stabbed her back by pushing Helen to fire her. With the help from Lance, with whom she reunites, they reveal Jill as a spy for a rival company. Jill is fired on the spot, and not only is Krissy rehired, she gets a big promotion. In the end, Lance proposes to her and Krissy comes to terms with the Christmas spirit.

Cast