Mustafi is the surname of:
Cricketers
Sisir Mustafi (born 1920), played for Bengal 1941–1950
Ashoke Mustafi (born 1933), played for Bengal 1958/59
Footballers
Nebi Mustafi (born 1976), Albanian–Macedonian, has played for various clubs, and for the Republic of Macedonia
Nuri Mustafi (born 1983), Macedonian, plays for Brønshøj BK (Denmark)
Orhan Mustafi (born 1990), Macedonian, plays for FC Le Mont (Switzerland)
Shkodran Mustafi (born 1992), German, plays for Arsenal F.C. and for the German national football team.