7.4 /10 1 Votes
Language English Media type Hardcover, Paperback Publisher Random House Country United Kingdom | 3.7/5 Goodreads Publication date 2006 Originally published 2006 Genre Military science Subject Armed forces | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Lions, Donkeys and Dinosaurs is a non-fiction book by Lewis Page criticising the British Armed Forces for waste and incompetence.
Contents
Background and contents
Page contends that inter-service rivalry, bureaucracy and second-rate equipment waste taxpayer's money and risk the lives of soldiers. He is particularly critical of the Eurofighter Typhoon, the Type 45 destroyer and the Nimrod MRA4 maritime patrol aircraft as being both overpriced and of little military value. Above all, he criticises BAE Systems, the British defence company involved in these projects, for huge cost-overruns and poor workmanship. He argues that the UK government should purchase cheaper and better weapons from foreign sources (usually American), rather than continue to prop up BAE.
Page argues that some weapons, including heavy artillery, tanks, frigates and destroyers, are rendered obsolete by modern airpower and that the UK should scrap most or all of its capacity in these areas.
Reception and reviews
Max Hastings, writing in the Daily Telegraph, praised the force and humour of the writing, and the comprehensive and informed nature of the criticism. Nicholas Fearn, in The Independent stated the book deserved to be a best-seller, although objected to Page's exclusive focus on the need for fighting current wars. However, The Times stated that the book was "shot through with inaccuracies", as if the author "seems to believe everything he was told". The Times added that 's "remarks are frequently facile, which undermines his judgment on important procurement issues he raises."