Killing Me Softly with Her Song (album)

Reception

William Ruhlmann of AllMusic described the place of this album within the Easy Listening genre in his review. "The early 1970s was a tough time for established ballad singers, but Johnny Mathis, who was younger than his peers and Columbia Records labelmates like Tony Bennett and Andy Williams, weathered the lean times better than most. Some of the reasons why are suggested in this 1973 album. It wasn't a big seller by any means, but this enjoyable, contemporary-sounding set made the charts." He also points out that "unlike Bennett, who had [left] Columbia the year before, Mathis had no resistance to contemporary material; he sounded fine singing it. And though he had never had much of an impact in the R&B market, he was an African-American who could handle the Stylistics and Gladys Knight songs credibly, substituting his trademark tremulousness for their more soulful approach. At the same time, he could match both Perry Como and newer soft-rock stars like Bread and the Carpenters."

At the time of the album's release, Billboard also had good things to say. "If you believe in masterpieces, then this LP qualifies." Already aware of the plans for his subsequent album, I'm Coming Home, which focused on new material, the magazine prematurely declared this as the end of his cover album phase. "Although Mathis is now on a path to record original songs, this last in his series of covering tunes is a totally rewarding listening experience." (Mathis would continue to record albums that included a varying number of current hit songs by other artists until the late 1970s.) The magazine was quite impressed with this project. "Mathis may have been recording for 17 years, but this newest work is magical. His clean, sweetly flowing voice is married perfectly to so many fine and outstanding songs that one wonders why they weren't presented to him in the first place. He makes them all come alive." They also appreciated the arrangements here. "There is a fine, gossamer feeling to D'Arneill Pershing's charts which makes the music more than merely commercially romantic."

Side one

1. "Killing Me Softly with Her Song" (Charles Fox, Norman Gimbel) – 5:18
2. "Aubrey" (David Gates) – 3:37
3. "And I Love You So" (Don McLean) – 3:26
4. "Break Up to Make Up" (Thom Bell, Linda Creed, Kenneth Gamble) – 3:50
5. "Arianne" (Martin Charnin, Christian Roudey) – 3:29

Side two

1. "Neither One of Us (Wants to Be the First to Say Goodbye)" (Jim Weatherly) – 4:26
2. "Wildflower" (Doug Edwards, David Richardson) – 4:21
3. "You Are the Sunshine of My Life" (Stevie Wonder) – 2:41
4. "Sing" from Sesame Street (Joe Raposo) – 3:04
5. "Good Morning Heartache" (Ervin Drake, Dan Fisher, Irene Higginbotham) – 2:25
6. "Show and Tell" (Jerry Fuller) – 3:12

Personnel